Currently I have two lip oil from different brand. This Juicy Shaker works in moisturizing very well but because the skin on my lip is too dry and thin, I need something thicker. The other one I have is Clarins Instant Light Lip Comfort Oil which is more like a thick lip oil. Similar to a lip gloss, only not as tacky as lip gloss. That one works better for me and keeps the pain at bay. I was also told that one works like a lip treatment. You can apply it to bed. Which I did as my lip now are chaffing like crazy due to the allergy attack.